Randy's Blog

RSS Feed
Healthcare – the Commonsense Way
Posted by Randy | November 18, 2009


It’s not too late to get healthcare reform right, so every American has more choice, better quality, and more access to healthcare. I’ve joined former speaker of the House Newt Gingrich and several other members of Congress in signing this letter to President Obama, Speaker Pelosi, and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, outlining eight commonsense principles to find the right solutions in healthcare.

Here’s the letter. Do you support these principles?


November 18, 2009

The Honorable Barack Obama
President of the United States
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20500

The Honorable Nancy Pelosi
Speaker of the House
United States House of Representatives
The U.S. Capitol, Room H-232
Washington, D.C. 20510

The Honorable Harry Reid
Senate Majority Leader
United States Senate
The U.S. Capitol, Room S-221
Washington, D.C. 20510

Dear President Obama, Speaker Pelosi, and Leader Reid:

There is no doubt that improving healthcare for all Americans is one of our country’s top priorities. From the quality of care to how much we pay, from insurance coverage to access, from treatments to technology, healthcare profoundly affects every American, every community, and every business.

We can all agree that we need to work together so that every American has more choices of greater quality at lower cost.

Unfortunately, the last several months have shown yet again that many in Washington are more interested in playing politics than achieving a positive result for the American people. It is not too late. There is still an opportunity to get health reform right. Here are commonsense ways to find the right solutions, the right way.

Slow down. Ramming through a trillion-dollar bill without giving three hundred million Americans the chance to study the legislation raises legitimate questions of why some leaders are trying to avoid a careful review by the American people. In a democracy, a secretive, one-sided process is never the right way to govern.

Open up. A 2,000-page bill written in secret by a handful of politicians and staff is the wrong way. Republicans have offered time and time again to bring constructive ideas to the table, only to be shut out by a cold shoulder and a closed door. We need an honest and open process free of artificial, political deadlines and open to input from everyone. Cooperation, not confrontation, is a better approach.

Don’t break the bank. The director of the Congressional Budget Office said this in July:

“In the legislation that has been reported we do not see the sort of fundamental changes that would be necessary to reduce the trajectory of federal health spending by a significant amount. And on the contrary, the legislation significantly expands the federal responsibility for healthcare costs.”

Nothing has changed since then to bend the cost curve down. Why should the American people believe that spending another $1 trillion will somehow reduce healthcare costs? Why should the American people believe that a $1 trillion price tag from Washington won’t put our country further into debt? Why should governors and state officials believe that the largest unfunded mandate in American history will not break their banks when they are on the hook to pay for these reforms? With unemployment at 10 percent and with more than $9 trillion in federal debt on the horizon, why commit to spending another trillion dollars before stopping the waste, fraud, abuse and mismanagement in current government programs (Medicare and Medicaid) first?

Reform does not mean replace. The vast majority of Americans are satisfied with their current coverage and doctors, a fact that has been borne out in every public opinion study for years. Improvements must certainly be made to make health insurance more portable, more accessible, and more affordable, but our first priority should be to protect and strengthen what the American people already have and support.

The right reforms. Neither party has a monopoly on sound solutions. Good ideas and sound decision-making, regardless of their origin, are desperately needed. For example, the Congressional Budget Office recently concluded that reforming medical liability laws would save the federal government $54 billion. Despite these important savings and overwhelming support from the American people, medical liability reform has never been part of the discussion because of political reasons. Where money can be saved, it must be. This is particularly true today, given the fragile state of the economy and this year’s record budget deficit.

Real competition and real choice. You talk often about the important principles of “competition and choice.” We enthusiastically agree. But instead of creating one huge government-run insurance plan, let’s break down the existing barriers to greater competition. A better approach is a nationwide marketplace where all 1,300 insurance companies are forced to compete, giving Americans real choices. This will bring down costs and improve quality—just as it does wherever competition is allowed to flourish.

Save Medicare from bankruptcy. The non-partisan Medicare Trustees concluded that Medicare will be broke in eight years. Medicare already has an unfunded liability of at least $37 trillion in benefits that have been promised future generations. The emerging legislation does nothing to save Medicare. Rather than cutting Medicare to pay for new federal subsidies or a government-run insurance plan, we should save and strengthen it. The right way would be to root out the fraud, waste, and abuse first that is costing the current program tens of billions every year.

Unleash American innovation. Science, research, and innovation are a vital part of improving healthcare. We should reform the Food and Drug Administration to expedite the movement of drugs, devices, and new technologies to the market. We should invest in new science to cure diseases like Alzheimer’s and cancer. Inexplicably, the Senate Finance Committee goes in the other direction, raising more than $60 billion in new taxes on medical technology and drug research – the people responsible for the medical breakthroughs in America. These kinds of innovators should be rewarded, not punished.

Health reform or “health insurance reform” should not be a political wedge, pushed to satisfy political allies at the expense of the American people. Healthcare is too important and the stakes are too high. The American people deserve and have demanded better. With an honest process, the right priorities, and the right solutions, we can and will succeed.

Sincerely,

Newt Gingrich, Former Speaker of the House; Founder, Center for Health Transformation

Jeb Bush, Former Governor of Florida

Mike Huckabee, Former Governor of Arkansas

Michael O. Leavitt, Former Governor of Utah; Former Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Mark Sanford, Governor of South Carolina

Senator Richard Burr of North Carolina

Senator Saxby Chambliss of Georgia

Senator Tom Coburn of Oklahoma

Senator Roger Wicker of Mississippi

Rep. Michele Bachmann of Minnesota

Rep. Roscoe Bartlett of Maryland

Rep. Roy Blunt of Missouri

Rep. Dave Camp of Michigan

Rep. John Campbell of California

Rep. Bill Cassidy of Louisiana

Rep. Charles Dent of Pennsylvania

Rep. Jo Ann Emerson of Missouri

Rep. Randy Forbes of Virginia

Rep. Phil Gingrey of Georgia

Rep. Louie Gohmert of Texas

Rep. Dean Heller of Nevada

Rep. Jeb Hensarling of Texas

Rep. Pete Hoekstra of Michigan

Rep. Darrell Issa of California

Rep. Mark Kirk of Illinois

Rep. John Linder of Georgia

Rep. Kevin McCarthy of California

Rep. Thaddeus McCotter of Michigan

Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers of Washington

Rep. Tim Murphy of Pennsylvania

Rep. Sue Myrick of North Carolina

Rep. Devin Nunes of California

Rep. Tom Price of Georgia

Rep. Dave Reichert of Washington

Rep. Paul Ryan of Wisconsin

Rep. Pete Sessions of Texas

Rep. John Shadegg of Arizona

Rep. William “Mac” Thornberry of Texas

Rep. Lynn Westmoreland of Georgia

Rep. Frank Wolf of Virginia

Fmr. Rep. Sue Kelly of New York

Fmr. Rep. David McIntosh of Indiana

Douglas Holtz-Eakin, Former Director, Congressional Budget Office

Benjamin E. Sasse, Former Assistant Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

David Brailer, Former National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

James C. Capretta, Former Associate Director for Human Resource Programs, Office of Management and Budget

Andrew von Eschenbach, Former Director, National Cancer Institute; Former Commissioner, U.S. Food and Drug Administration

Tevi Troy, Former Deputy Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Comments
The opinions expressed below are those of their respective authors and do not necessarily represent those of this office.
  • Kevin Gunn commented on 11/18/2009
    I couldn't agree more. "Government-run healthcare" doesn't make sense, even on the surface. Anything that's "government-run" just means more power for those with power. They're not kidding anyone with the altruistic rhetoric. And the government does not and can not "compete" with private industry. The public/private college analogy is insultingly misleading--private colleges don't "compete" with public ones...it's two different markets...private colleges compete with private colleges and public colleges compete with public colleges... Anyway, keep up the good fight!
  • Mark Cernak commented on 11/18/2009
    Congress and the President are not listening to the American public the majority say leave the healthcare system as is. Why do they want to jam this down are throats especially when the economy is so bad! Senator Warner said they can not just do nothing but I differ I think Congress should do less that would be a good thing. How can we turn over healthcare to Congress you know the one that is managing medicare, medicaid, amtrack, social security and post office (who will lose 7 billion dollars this year) all of which are bankrupt big time!! And don't you like how the Democrats and President are delaying the announcement of the new Strategy in Afganistan for weeks, wonder if the Tailban has gotten that memo since they are still killing are soliders! They are delaying the announcement on the miltary strategy because they want to vote a healthcare bill this week before they announce the new stategry which the American people will not like. They are not going to send the 40,000 troops needed to win the war there only enough troops so we will not win the Battle that why they are playing games with our soldiers lives.
  • Eric Rakes commented on 11/19/2009
    This is a beautifully crafted letter that I hope will save us all from terrible shortcomings as a result of knee-jerk voting in the US. Thank you again for your hard work keeping America free.
  • Byron Ward commented on 11/19/2009
    Sadly, for our republic, all of the suggestions in the letter make good common financial sense for our republic and in alignment with my thoughts and concerns, as well. What troubles me most is, given that the concerns are legitimate and compelling, nobody, including our President, seems to be taking any of this seriously. Have Democrats and Republicans become so vastly different from each other and so polarized that neither represents the constituency they were elected to serve and exist only to prove the other wrong while ignoring the tremendously high stakes game they play? We press forward headlong to generations of crippling debt, with all of its political and economic ramifications. We press forward to create yet another bloated inefficient and generally incompetent government bureaucracy that will further intrude into our personal lives and personal freedoms and take even more of our hard earned money from our pockets. I fear for our republic. I see this letter as a step in the right direction and I would like to see Senator Reid's response when and if it is ever received.
  • Bonita Ridlon commented on 11/20/2009
    I believe this bill will cost more than we can afford to pay. Please try to work together for a good compromise. I truly get the feeling the democrats want this bill passed because they are power hungry. The american people love this country and want everyone to have good health care. This bill however is not the way to get it. Thank You Bonita Ridlon
  • Mark Cernak Sr. commented on 11/20/2009
    I have a question for this healthcare bill in the Senate beyond just are the Senators going to read the 2000 page plus bill but how much are they going to comprehend after reading the bill. Can you imagine reading a 2000 page book you "like" and how much of it would you remember! Then try and read the heathcare bill which if filled with so much legal terminology and what would you remember!
  • Alice Hedish commented on 11/20/2009
    We need to pull these United States back together... Please help...
  • Linda Taylor commented on 11/23/2009
    Medicare, auto ownership, homeowners, floods, etc... These insurances are NOT MANDATED. No one has to own a car; if we choose to, but the coverage and cost, that’s affordable to us anywhere in the U.S., is not mandated... The same for Homeowner’s ins., it is not mandatory. Neither is Flood Ins; a prime example of what happens when the govt underbids insurance companies; the govt now our only option. Medicaid, that strips every bit of self-esteem one ever had; and you have to be rock bottom to get it, and it only pays doctors $8-$10/visit. There are NO mandates for Medicare...YET. When I turned 65, my BCBS would only pay Medicare's cost, which is 80% of the prices Medicare sets for the treatment. Ex: I have to have an outpatient kidney/bladder procedure every 6 months that takes about 2 hours. My Urology/Oncology Specialist charged $2500+ BCBS at Medicare prices that only allowed $396 for the procedure. Can you see a lawyer accepting 1/6 of the cost he charges? Yet Congress comes down on insurance companies and doctors, but won’t even consider tort reform for lawsuits. Bottom line, these are our own personal choices, but you want to mandate (govt approved coverage) health INSURANCE for everyone, penalizing through taxes on gross income, fines, even jail time, starting immediately, but “benefits,” not until 2014... and YOU DARE CALL THIS CONSTITUTIONAL? I think it’s somewhere between socialism and Marxism.
  • JEAN OLIVER-NEWMAN commented on 11/25/2009
    THANK GOD FOR THOSE THAT UNDERSTAND THE PROBLEMS. MAY THE LORD BE WITH YOU....
  • Ernest Jackson commented on 12/6/2009
    There is nothing that the government does not have a hand in from the day you are born to the day you die. That is the question that everyone seems not to take note of. Freedom is what the government of the people dole out to its constituence. Democracy is an albatross for the unlearned, and Socialism prevails in all aspects of life of every United States Citizen. That is the question all american should be asking. What is happening? Why the denial? The Bilderberg Group envisions global rule involvement in not only third world nations, including the USA. Vote to stop the encroachment. Global rule simply leads to entrenched slavery and more killings in the name of progress and civility.
  • Mark Cernak commented on 12/22/2009
    Numerous states are getting something for the closture vote bu tVirginia is not listed. Why is Virginia a second hand state and not getting anything but we will pay for what other states are getting!!! Does Virginia get not respect. Sen. Ben Nelson (D-NE) won a provision exempting his state from paying the usual share of costs for new Medicaid patients. The deal, which critics have dubbed the "Cornhusker Kickback," is expected to cost the federal government $100 million over 10 years. Before a close vote last month, Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-LA) won an even larger break for her state -- an estimated $300 million in extra federal spending, in a move now derisively called the "Louisiana Purchase." Sen. Carl Levin (D-MI) made sure that certain insurance companies in his state are off the hook from a new $7 billion dollar tax. Sen. Chris Dodd (D-CT) got his kickback -- a $100 million bonus for the University of Connecticut… to do with whatever they want. Sen. Bernie Sanders (D-VT) was "persuaded" to drop his concerns after Senator Reid offered his state a $10 billion grant for "community health centers"-money that could easily be funneled to facilities that perform abortions. Three states -- Pennsylvania, New York and Florida -- all won protections for their Medicare Advantage beneficiaries at a time when the program is facing cuts nationwide. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) won a promise from Reid to support his plan to expand eligibility for health insurance. The Senators from Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Utah and Wyoming will get the "Frontier Freebie" -- they'll see an increase in Medicare payments to hospitals and doctors, because "at least 50 percent of their counties are ‘frontier counties,' defined as those having a population density less than six people per square mile." Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA), chairman of the Senate health committee, got a provision inserted to increase Medicare payments to certain "low-volume hospitals" in Grinnell, Keokuk and Spirit Lake, treating limited numbers of Medicare patients.
  • Kaye Botelis commented on 12/26/2009
    I was born in the United States of America not in a socialist country. I believe in my freedom and I do not want a government that has a hand in my personal life, spirtitual beliefs or my health care. I never thought I'd live to see a government that actually would go after private citizens and news stations that do not agree with what they have to say. We have socialist in the President's cabinet and if they are pointed out they just move them to a different office thinking we won't notice. Even Hollywood is trying to run the government. Are you people crazy? We pay for the plane and crew to send the President's wife and one of the richest women in the world Oprah Winfrey to try to get the Olympics to come to Chicago and then the next day we pay for Air Force One to take the President on the same mission. As anybody with good sense knows it takes more than 3 days to get the Olympics anywhere. But Washington continues to want to throw our money around like it belongs to them. Good luck boys because President Barack O'bama, Sen Jas. Webb, Sen Mark Warner, Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the House (who by the way hears footsteps running behind her) and Harry Reid Senate Majority Leader, elections will be coming up and I plan on being the first in line to vote. Your time is running out. See you at the polls.
Post a Comment
We encourage you to analyze and comment on the posts featured on this blog, but please understand that comments including inappropriate language or personal attacks will be removed from the site. Please note that there may be a brief delay in the publication of your comment. Users are solely responsible for the opinions they post here and their comments do not necessarily reflect the views of Congressman Forbes.